Best restaurants in Door County

chives

Nestled in Door County, Chives embodies a perfect blend of upscale dining with a casual flair. This restaurant, known for its refined yet relaxed atmosphere, offers a delightful culinary experience. Situated away from the bustling main streets, Chives surprises diners with its creative dishes crafted from top-quality local ingredients. Beyond the savory delights, what truly steals the show at Chives are its exceptional desserts, some of the best we’ve ever tried. With a menu that combines sophistication and comfort, Chives stands as a top choice for those looking to indulge in an elevated dining experience with a touch of casual charm in Door County.

White Gull Inn

The While Gull Inn is well known for their famous Door County Cherry Stuffed French Toast. It’s literally two pieces of homemade french toast stuffed with cream cheese and cherries. It is just.as.good as it sounds and all other breakfast food is garbage in comparison.

Nightingale Supper Club

The very first thing we did when we got to Door County was immediately search for a good Supper Club so we could stuff our face with Friday Night Fish Fry. Nightingale Supper Club is located at the very bottom of the Door County peninsula so it’s the perfect place to stop at on your way to central Door County. Don’t forget to order the Brandy Old Fashioned.

Door County Creamery

We stumbled upon Door County Creamery while walking through Sister Bay. We were looking for a brunch spot but once we sampled all the cheeses at the counter we quickly decided one GIANT Cheese and Charcuterie Board was the perfect brunch.

The Cheese and Charcuterie Board has Bandaged Cheddar, Blue Cheese, Fresh Goat Cheese, Tripe Cream Brie, Sea Salt & Olive Oil Ciabatta Cracker, Figs, Dates, Olives, 400 Day Proscuitto, Coppa, Salami, Wild Board Sausage, Spicy Calabrese, Spinach Chorizo, Soppressata.

Alexander’s of Door County

We visited Alexander’s one cold Monday in February. Winter is Door County is magical and quiet and a nice dinner after a day spent outside was absolutely perfect. Mike got this Rack of Lamb with Balsamic Roasted Vegetables and Scalloped Potatoes. The Creme Brûlée for dessert was also a great treat! Alexander’s is on the pricer side, so definitely save it for a special occasion or nice dinner.

Trixie’s

Whenever we travel anywhere we always set aside one night for a NICE AF meal. When we asked our Instagram followers for recommendations, Trixie’s is where everyone recommended we go. They unfortunately don’t take reservations, so we simply showed up right at 4:30 when they opened. We got a table right away and the food was just as amazing as everyone described.

We ordered Tuna Ceviche, Mochi Cake with Strawberry Rhubarb Sauce, NY Strip with Creamed Spinach and Grilled Whole Trout with Sweet & Sour Curry Tomato Chutney, Fried Brussel Sprouts and Raita.

Roots INN

In Door County, there’s this awesome farm-to-table spot called Roots that’s all about the freshest local ingredients. It’s a bit of a hidden gem, tucked away from the main scene, but totally worth finding. The chefs here are all about creative dishes, and what’s cool is that they keep it budget-friendly. So, if you’re up for a unique farm-to-table experience that won’t break the bank, Roots is the place to be in Door County – casual vibes and seriously fresh eats!

Hungry for more?

Sign up for our newsletter!